Theology: A Waste of Time?

Theology often gets a bad rap. What's the point of formulating doctrine when we already have Scripture? Why engage in intellectual discourse when nothing seems to get resolved? Why try to solve problems that may be unsolvable, or spend time discussing abstract topics with no practical impact?
We might call this theological pessimism: skepticism about the value of theological discussion and its results.
Theology shapes what we do. In fact, practical theology is an entire branch of the discipline devoted to this application, dealing with worship styles and practices and how to handle situations in the local church.
Let me start by saying that you’re right: theology can be a waste of time—but only when it’s done poorly. It can become overly abstract. I’m reminded of Marco Rubio’s comment onstage: “We need more engineers and fewer philosophers.” In other words, we need fewer thinkers and more doers. In some ways, I think he's right. In other ways, I think that view is naïve.
What would happen if we removed thinkers from society? What kind of culture would we have without people who reflect on the truth of God's revelation? Would our society be better or worse? I believe it would be worse, because it would be shaped more by emotion than by truth. Truth is the foundation of what we do, and pursuing truth is the work of theologians and philosophers.
Highly abstract questions—such as the nature and reality of time, the existence of abstract objects, and other metaphysical topics—may be best left to Christian philosophers, unless you feel drawn to study them yourself. But remember, philosophical theology is only one branch of theological study. It is not all of theology.
Theological pessimists may simply have little interest in systematic theology or in theology more broadly. Imagine you’re in grade school, taking the usual subjects: history, science, math, and language arts. Suppose you're doing well in history, math, and language but struggling in science. How might you view science? Would you see it as worthwhile, or as a waste of time?
When someone dismisses theology as a waste of time, that judgment may reflect difficulty engaging with an intellectual discipline outside their comfort zone. In a similar way, a negative attitude toward theology may stem from a lack of interest or from not knowing how to engage with it well.
My point is that theology, understood for what it is, is surely not a waste of time. Those who think it is may not fully understand what theology involves. I define theology as the study of God's revelation for our edification. If you’re a Christian and find yourself reading that definition and thinking, “I want no part of this,” I would have serious concerns.
Part of being a Christian is seeking God and the knowledge of himself that he reveals. To ignore the study of God's revelation is, in a sense, to ignore God himself.
Perhaps the pessimists are right: if we have Scripture, maybe there is no need for abstract theology. But I would encourage anyone who thinks this to consider how we interpret Scripture. We cannot take Scripture entirely at face value—we interpret with our minds. Our biases and preferences shape the way we read and understand it. That is why we need sound biblical studies to help us interpret Scripture well.
If you value exegesis and biblical studies but disagree with systematic theology, consider this question: Once we have interpreted Scripture, what do we do with it? How do we understand what Scripture teaches collectively about a particular topic? That is the task of systematic theology.
When we apply these questions to the lives of everyday Christians, it becomes clear that they do need theology. This leads me to believe that some people misunderstand what theology actually is.
I have defined systematic theology to include edification. Most contemporary theologians I know recognize and emphasize that theology is not merely abstract or intellectual; it is practical. Theology shapes what we do. In fact, practical theology is an entire branch of the discipline devoted to this application, dealing with worship styles and practices and how to handle situations in the local church.
Engaging in theological study can benefit people in many ways: it can deepen their personal relationship with God, strengthen their confidence in the rational justification of their faith and the accuracy of their interpretations of Scripture, and shape the theological beliefs that influence how they worship and relate to one another in the body of Christ.
I believe there are two main reasons someone might consider theology a waste of time: they may simply be uninterested in the way the subject has been presented to them, or they may misunderstand what theology is and what it is meant to accomplish.
The very definition of theology points to the tangible, practical benefits of studying God's revelation. So, while some theology may seem like a waste of time because it is overly abstract, that is not true of theology as a whole.
Theology is not a waste of time; it should be an essential part of every Christian’s life because it shapes how we live and worship our Creator. Theologians pursue their work out of love for God, and that love is what drives and motivates the study of God. This applies just as much to laypeople. So, instead of asking whether theology is a waste of time, we might ask: If we don't study theology, are we truly loving God with our minds?




Comments