top of page

Answering 15 Challenges to Christianity

Oct 29
7 min read

Books could be written about any of these questions. This article is not meant to provide exhaustive responses, but to practice the art of effective concision. How well can we give quick and consie answers that make a difference for skeptics' lives?


1) “Jesus probably never existed. There’s no real evidence for him outside the Bible.”


Response: That’s quite a radical claim; do you have any evidence that suggests Jesus never existed? I have yet to find a single reliable New Testament historian who denies that Jesus was a real historical person. Do you know any? NT historian Bart Ehrman, who is himself an ardent skeptic of Christianity, has said it would be “foolish” to deny that Jesus was a real historical person. The Gospels are early eyewitness accounts of Jesus based on the plethora of evidence. Additionally, you seem to assume they are unreliable. What is your evidence? If you’re concerned about bias, isn’t it true that all historical sources have bias? Outside of the Bible, there are early Jewish (e.g., Josephus) and Roman (e.g., Tacitus) sources that affirm the historicity of Jesus.


2) “The Gospels were written decades after Jesus died. By then the stories were exaggerated, like a game of telephone.”


Response: Indeed, the Gospels were written just decades after the historical events, which is extraordinarily early in comparison to other ancient sources. For example, accounts of Alexander the Great were written over 300 years after his death. You assume “the stories were exaggerated.” Is this a baseless assumption or do you have evidence to base it on?  The Gospel accounts are not like a game of telephone because these are direct accounts from an eyewitness or close associates of an eyewitness.


3) “The Bible is just copies of copies of copies. It’s been changed so many times that we can’t know what the originals said.”


Response: What do you mean when you say, “it has been changed?” If you mean there are variations within manuscripts, well, of course there are. What would you expect from over 5,800 Greek NT manuscripts? Textual critics have studied those manuscripts and reconstructed them with over 99% accuracy to the original writings. The 1% uncertainty includes insignificant discrepancies that anyone would expect from thousands of manuscripts being copied by hand. This vast number of ancient manuscripts is unprecedented: for instance, Aristotle died in 322 BC; the oldest manuscripts of his works date to AD 1100 (a 1,400-year gap); and there are only 49 total manuscripts (the NT has over 5,800). Why do you think the manuscript evidence isn’t reliable?


4) "The church decided which books made it into the Bible and left out others (like the Gospel of Thomas) to control what people believe.”


Response: The church did not “decide” arbitrarily which books were part of the Bible; rather, they discovered which books were inspired by God through a careful assessment using certain criteria: (1) must have been written by an eyewitness or a close associate; (2) must be consistent with other biblical teachings; and (3) must be universally accessible to the churches rather than isolated to a specific people or place. Gnostic gospels such as the Gospel of Thomas, along with others, were rejected as Scripture because they did not meet those criteria. Moreover, you asserted that they did this “to control what people believe.” What evidence do you have to support this claim?


5) “The Bible contradicts itself all over the place, so it can’t really be God’s Word.”


Response: Could you give me some examples where you think the Bible contradicts itself? Once I know what passages you have in mind, I can explain why, given proper context, they appear to contradict but don’t actually contradict. Moreover, even if two biblical passages contradicted each other on a relatively insignificant matter, would that prove the central claim of Christianity, the resurrection, never happened?


6) “The God of the Old Testament is violent and cruel. He commands wars and even wipes out entire groups of people.”


Response: Could you show me some examples of what you mean by God's violence? As I await your examples, here are some general ways to guide our thinking on this: (1) God is the author of life and therefore has every right to freely give and freely take life as He sees fit; (2) there is much about the Ancient Near Eastern context that ought to be factored; (3) a possible justification for using the Israelites as a means to a desired outcome, which may entail violence, is the extreme sinfulness of foreign nations, who could themselves be extremely violent and heinous; (4) the examples of questionable violence do not negate all of the many passages of God’s love (e.g., Deut 7:7-9); and (5) the God of the OT is the same as the God of the NT, which speaks of the immensity of His love for us through Jesus Christ.


7) “The Bible supports slavery, so how can it be a moral book?”


Response: Slavery in the ancient world is not the same type of slavery we think of today. In the Ancient Near East, slavery was often an opportunity for livelihood. For instance, if someone owed a financial debt, they might choose to become enslaved to work it off. Unlike the enslavement of African Americans, slavery in the biblical context was not based on race but on socioeconomic functions.


8) “The Bible is anti-women and treats them as second-class.”


Response: Given the Ancient Near Eastern context, the Bible actually goes against the cultural norm in its impartial treatment of women: the salvation of Rahab, the elevated view of female figures such as Ruth and Esther; and in Jesus’s ministry, we see the healing of the bleeding woman, preventing the adulterous woman from being stoned, the revealing of His Messiahship to a Canaanite woman, and, of course, the necessary roles of the women who discovered the empty tomb (whose testimony would’ve otherwise been inconsequential). How do you think Jesus treated women?


9) “The Bible is anti-science. You have to choose between believing it and believing modern science.”


Response. This is a false dichotomy. Nothing in Scripture negates the legitimacy of science. On the contrary, science makes the most sense if the kind of universe we live in was designed for a purpose. What do you think is anti-science in the Bible?


10) “If God is real and good, why do innocent people suffer? Why didn’t He stop it?"


Response: This requires a longer response, but to begin a framework, remember that no one is truly innocent—all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God (Rom 3:23). Additionally, God allows suffering because the reality of human free will is highly valuable: it creates the possibility for humankind to have a real loving relationship with God, but it also includes the potential for great evil ultimately stemming from sin. What do you think is more important: living without suffering for a short life or living in fellowship with God in everlasting bliss?


11) “Christian are hypocrites. They preach love, then post hateful stuff online or cover up scandals in their own churches.”


Response: Some of them certainly are. I’ve experienced some of them myself. However, what some Christians have done is not representative of Jesus Christ. In fact, don’t we know these Christians are hypocrites precisely because of the truth of biblical teachings?


12) “Christianity is just a political team now. Churches pick a side and use God to win elections.”


Response: I agree that some churches, both on the right and the left, have an unbiblical view of church involvement in politics. Regardless, do you vote? Wouldn’t you want to “win elections” based on your moral beliefs?


13) “Saying Jesus is the only way to God is arrogant. What about people of other religions, or people who have never heard of him? Would a loving God really send them to hell?"


Response: Many questions need to be unpacked here. But to begin, Christians are not being arrogant; this is a matter of logic. Two contradictory things cannot both be true. For instance, Islam and Judaism believe God to be one person, whereas Christianity believes God is three persons. Both sides cannot be true at the same time. Religions naturally exclude other religions since they make truth claims. Christians believe Jesus when He claimed to be the way, the truth, and the life (John 14:6); therefore, they share the gospel out of love. If you knew someone was sick and dying, would you tell them so, or would you avoid telling them because you thought it might be arrogant to say as someone who is not suffering from the same illness?


14) “Christianity is homophobic. The church’s teaching on sexuality and gender is outdated and hurts people.”


Response: Heterosexuals suffer from the same disease—sin. We are all in need of a Savior. God created human beings with the intention of one man and one woman becoming one flesh. This is our design. For those who experience same-sex attraction, understand that this teaching is not a personal attack. We all have desires that don’t align with God’s perfect design. The truth is objective and therefore does not change with cultural trends or feelings. Homosexuals have the same call as heterosexuals: Commitment to an everlasting relationship with Jesus Christ and allow Him to transform the desires of your heart.


15) “Faith is just believing without evidence. Science explains everything now, and God is a crutch for people who can’t handle reality.”


Response: Some people of faith may suffer from blind faith—irrational belief with no foundation of reason—but I can attest that mine is not so. I have seen the evidence of Jesus’s work in my life. Moreover, I have studied the evidence for God’s existence. Would you like to hear an argument (e.g., the argument from contingency, the ontological argument, the Kalam cosmological argument, the fine-tuning argument, the argument from the applicability of mathematics, or the moral argument), or would you like to hear about the evidence for the resurrection (e.g., the minimal facts argument)? As a follow-up, if science is the methodology of empirical observation and inference, and you say it can explain everything, how can it explain morality, aesthetics, logic, or science itself?

 

 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page