Blood Sacrifice and the Command to Forgive

Why does God require torture and blood sacrifice while simultaneously commanding us to forgive others? How can these expectations be reconciled?
This question often sparks curiosity among Christians. At first glance, both premises appear to follow from a straightforward reading of Scripture: (1) God required His Son to be crucified for humanity’s sins, and (2) Scripture repeatedly commands us to forgive. Consider the following passages:
“Going a little farther, he fell with his face to the ground and prayed, ‘My Father, if it is possible, may this cup be taken from me. Yet not as I will, but as you will’” (Matt. 26:39).
“For if you forgive other people when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins.” (Matt 6:14-15).
“‘And when you stand praying, if you hold anything against anyone, forgive them, so that your Father in heaven may forgive you your sins’” (Mark 11:25).
“‘Do not judge, and you will not be judged. Do not condemn, and you will not be condemned. Forgive, and you will be forgiven’” (Luke 6:37).
“Be kind and compassionate to one another, forgiving each other, just as in Christ God forgave you” (Eph 4:32).
How should we understand this apparent tension? God’s actions may seem inconsistent with what He asks of us. If He calls us to forgive without demanding a blood sacrifice, why did He require one from His Son? What about God compels Him to exercise wrath while also calling us to forgive without doing so?
It may seem intuitive that, because God is just, He requires some form of punishment for wrongdoing. And if God calls us to be like Him—and therefore to act justly—we might conclude that we, too, should require punishment for offenses committed against us.
One response is that Jesus bore God’s wrath once and for all, covering the sins of those who are in Christ (Heb 9–10) and thereby enabling us to forgive others. I am not convinced, however, that this fully addresses the question. Christ’s commands to forgive in Matthew, Mark, and Luke do not indicate that His impending atoning death is relevant to the commands themselves. He does not say, “Forgive others because my death will enable you to do so.” Nor do I think He means that failing to forgive others makes salvation impossible. Rather, Christ calls us to embody the kind of love He demonstrated during His earthly life.
How, then, should we respond to the question? I contend that we can begin by distinguishing between two kinds of forgiveness: relational and judicial.
Relational forgiveness involves an outpouring of love from one person to another. It means saying, “Regardless of what has happened, I will forgive my brother or sister in Christ out of unconditional love and in recognition of our unity in the body of Christ.” Toward unbelievers, it means extending the same mercy and forgiveness that Christ showed us while we were still sinners. We refuse to hold their wrongdoing against them and forgive them in our hearts, though this does not necessarily mean forgetting.
Judicial forgiveness, by contrast, involves the payment of a debt through punishment. When wrongdoing occurs, a debt is incurred that must be paid. We hear this language in courts of law: “Your fines have been paid” or “Your debt has been forgiven”—for example, when someone has served a prison sentence. The same principle applies to sin. Because of our sin against God, a legal debt—a punishment—must be paid. As a just God, He cannot overlook that debt. Christ served as our proxy, or substitute, by bearing sin’s punishment and satisfying the debt.
This brings us back to the original question: Why does God require torture and blood sacrifice from Christ while commanding us to forgive others? The question assumes that forgiveness at the cross and the forgiveness we extend to others are the same kind. Christ’s atoning death primarily involves judicial forgiveness, though it also involves relational forgiveness. The command for us to forgive others, however, is not judicial.
For this reason, the claim that Christ’s atoning death covers all wrongdoing does not directly answer the question. Nor does it resolve the issue to note that God's nature is fully just, whereas our nature is sinful and we often fail to act justly.
When Christ commands us to forgive, He calls us to forgive others relationally, not judicially. God's command to uphold justice is distinct. We are called to forgive others in love, rather than administer justice. God is therefore not inconsistent in what He requires of Christ and of us. Distinguishing between these two kinds of forgiveness is key.




Comments