top of page

Christianity and Homosexuality

5 days ago
3 min read

Read a refutation of two primary arguments on homosexuality. These do not represent all of the affirming arguments, but I nevertheless hope to represent them charitably.


Argument 1: Sound Christian teaching should produce good fruit, not bad fruit. Studies indicate that LGBTQ young adults are more likely to experience depression and suicidality when they face family rejection. These are harmful outcomes, prompting us to reconsider the source of that fruit: our interpretation of Scripture. There are precedents for reinterpreting Scripture in light of past experience, including the decision not to require Gentiles to be circumcised and the rejection of slavery.


Response: This argument rightly observes that flawed interpretations of Scripture can produce harmful outcomes. However, its first weakness is the inference it draws from studies of young adults: it assumes that a non-affirming interpretation of Scripture necessarily leads to family rejection. Scripture does not command believers to reject family members because of their sexual orientation.


Luke 14:26 might be offered in response: “If anyone comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters—yes, even their own life—such a person cannot be my disciple.” Yet this reading takes the passage out of context. Jesus is speaking here about self-denial, not the rejection of gay family members. Indeed, those who rebuke children are repugnant to Christ (Mark 10:13-16).


Far from Scripture as the root: It would be unbiblical for a Christian household to disown a family member for experiencing same-sex attraction. What, then, are the bad fruits? The argument appears to treat non-affirming messages—such as describing homosexual lifestyles as sinful—as harmful outcomes in themselves; however, this reasoning is circular and therefore fallacious.


The source of our fruit lies not in our interpretation of Scripture, but in whether we are in Christ. A person may hold correct interpretations of Scripture while simultaneously bearing bad fruit. Therefore, a hermeneutic that treats personal experience as an indicator of truth is fallacious. Rather than imposing subjective experience on the text, a sound hermeneutic seeks to understand the text on its own terms and within its various contexts. In conclusion, this argument is unpersuasive because it conflates the source of our fruit and consequently relies on a flawed hermeneutic.



Argument #2: The arc of Scripture points toward inclusion, not exclusion. Early Christians rejected certain forms of same-sex behavior, rejecting promiscuity in favor of monogamy. Scripture condemned promiscuous same-sex behavior just as it condemned promiscuous heterosexual behavior. In the Old Testament, people considered sexually different—such as eunuchs and barren women—were excluded from certain blessings; in Christ, however, they are fully embraced.


Response: The argument’s initial premise is well founded: the Bible presents an unfolding story of God redeeming all people under one covenant. However, nothing indicates that the new covenant entails accepting sinful behavior in the name of inclusion. On the contrary, God established Israel as a light to the nations—not to adopt their pagan practices, but to reveal YHWH to them and transform them.


When Israel failed, God established a new people in Christ. Under this new covenant, Jews and Gentiles alike are sanctified through the indwelling of the Holy Spirit and formed into a people who reflect God. The gospel message is that people from all backgrounds come to faith in Christ and are transformed into his likeness. The Kingdom of God does not excuse immoral behavior; rather, it precludes it.


When Scripture condemns heterosexual behavior, it explicitly targets promiscuous conduct. By contrast, it does not make the same distinction when addressing same-sex behavior; instead, it appears to address homosexuality more broadly: “In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed shameful acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their error” (Rom. 1:27). As I read the passage, nothing in its context suggests that the error refers only to a particular kind of same-sex behavior. The text condemns the lust and sexual acts of men with one another. Scripture does not generalize heterosexuality in the same way.


Finally, the reference to barren women and eunuchs has no direct bearing on homosexuality: these conditions were physical, not ongoing patterns of sexual behavior.


In summary, this argument does not establish an affirmative case. It conflates Jesus’ teaching that people of every kind are included in the Kingdom with the moral permissibility of sinful behavior by those who are included, and it overlooks the call to sanctification.

 

Source:

The Reformation Project. “Brief Biblical Case for LGBTQ Inclusion.” Accessed March 22, 2024. https://reformationproject.org/biblical-case/

 
 
 

6 Comments


Brooks Norman
4 days ago

Interesting...

Like
nathan ulko
nathan ulko
4 days ago
Replying to

Thank you


Like

nathan ulko
nathan ulko
4 days ago

This is a careful, well-structured response that takes the affirming arguments seriously rather than dismissing them out of hand. You correctly note that Scripture never commands families to reject a child for same-sex attraction, and that equating non-affirming teaching itself with “bad fruit” risks circular reasoning. On the second argument, your distinction between inclusion of people and permission of behavior is especially clear, and the observation that Romans 1 does not parallel the limited, promiscuity-focused condemnations of heterosexual sin is hard to dismiss. The eunuch/barren-woman analogy is also fairly handled as a category error. Overall, the piece models the kind of precise, text-driven engagement the conversation needs.

Like
Brooks Norman
4 days ago
Replying to

Great analysis, Nathan! Very intellectual.

Like

sora
5 days ago

This really changed my perspective! Thanks!

Like

sora
5 days ago

This really changed my perspective! Thanks!

Like
bottom of page