Doctrinal Hierarchy

Doctrinal hierarchies are commonly recognized across the diverse fields of theology. This discussion considers several types of hierarchy within Christian theology.
Systematic theologies typically follow an organizational structure, beginning with revelation, Scripture, and creation, then proceeding to theology proper, humanity, sin, salvation, and eschatology, alongside many related doctrines. Some works instead open with theology proper (the doctrine of God), particularly when their authors adopt a more philosophical approach. The sequence varies according to each systematic theologian’s preferences, including the choice to omit certain doctrines. Nevertheless, most systematic theologies follow a broadly similar progression.
The rationale for this organizational structure is neither to begin with the most important doctrines and proceed to less significant ones, nor to build anticipation by reserving the most important doctrine for last. Rather, systematic theologians generally follow a similar structure because each doctrine rests on particular contextual presuppositions. In other words, the arrangement reflects logical priority: certain doctrines must be considered first to support a fuller understanding of those that follow.
For example, it would be unusual to discuss the doctrine of Scripture before the doctrine of revelation, since Scripture is a form of divine revelation. Similarly, discussing salvation before considering the implications of human sinfulness would be difficult. Readers therefore benefit from the intentional arrangement of doctrines in systematic theology. This arrangement represents one sense in which Christian doctrine can be said to have a hierarchy—not in terms of centrality or importance, but in the sense that the content of one doctrine is logically foundational to the content of another.
Theologians recognize several forms of hierarchy among Christian doctrines. One concerns the relative importance of particular doctrines. Yet importance is necessarily relative: important to whom, and for what purpose?
Christians intuitively regard some doctrines as central to their faith and others as less significant. For a biblically faithful Christian, the doctrine of inerrancy may be paramount; for an atheist considering Christianity, it may not be. Someone moving away from atheism might instead focus on the doctrine of Christ, setting aside premature disputes over apparent minor errors in the biblical text.
Some Christians may consider the doctrine of angels essential to their religious practice while viewing the doctrine of the Trinity as overly complex. Christian philosophers, by contrast, may regard the Trinity as more central.
Because judgments about the relative importance of Christian doctrines are subjective and context-dependent, theologians rarely discuss doctrinal hierarchy in terms of importance.
In most cases, the centrality of Christian doctrine within Christianity as a coherent system of faith provides the appropriate basis for establishing hierarchy. By “hierarchy” in terms of centrality, I do not mean a strict sequence in which one doctrine follows another until all doctrines have been ordered. Rather, I mean three encompassing categories, represented as a small circle, a larger circle surrounding it, and a third circle surrounding them both.

The outermost layer represents Level 1 doctrine, encompassing the most peripheral beliefs. These are doctrines on which Christians within a single local community can reasonably disagree. Differences between a person and a fellow member of their local church—including differences of which they are unaware—belong in this first layer. For example, if you believe the earth is billions of years old and discover that your pastor believes it is only a few thousand years old, would that lead you to leave your church? For most Christians, the answer would be no. As noted, some subjectivity is inevitable when determining where a particular doctrine falls within the hierarchy.
Moving to the next layer of the second circle, we encounter Level 2 doctrines—beliefs over which Christians in a local church cannot simply “agree to disagree.” Such doctrines often distinguish one denomination from another and may even lead to divisions within a denomination. For example, suppose you believe the Bible teaches that homosexuality is sinful, while your pastor publicly advocates an affirming position. Would this difference lead you to stop attending the church? If so, you would likely regard this belief as belonging to the second level of the hierarchy.
Consider, too, the differing views of the Eucharist. Many Catholics would not feel comfortable receiving communion in a Protestant church; for them, the doctrine of transubstantiation belongs in this middle layer. At the same time, Christians who approach Level 2 questions with deep piety, biblical integrity, and careful study may arrive at opposing conclusions.
Level 3 doctrines, the innermost layer of the hierarchy, are those considered nonnegotiable and most central to the Christian faith. Consider the hypothetical scenario of being aboard the sinking Titanic, with only minutes to explain the Christian faith to those around you and urge them to accept Christ. What would you say? Your response would likely center on Level 3 doctrines. Would you focus on the literary genre of Genesis or the doctrine of Satan? Probably not. Instead, you would present the central claims of the faith: Christ’s life, death, and resurrection; his teachings on sin and salvation; and the triunity of God. At the core of the hierarchy, Christians should exhibit the greatest degree of doctrinal unity.
To summarize the hierarchy most commonly encountered, Christian theology—both in its propositional claims and in the practical expression of faith—recognizes that some teachings are more central to Christianity than others. Level 1 doctrines concern comparatively minor beliefs over which members of a local congregation may disagree while remaining in fellowship. Level 2 doctrines involve more substantial differences that impede unity in worship and contribute to denominational distinctions. Level 3 doctrines are regarded as core tenets of Christianity and basic requirements for orthodoxy.




Comments