top of page

Is Atheism the Default Position?

Oct 26
3 min read

Atheists often attempt to define their view as the lack of belief in God: "It's not that we actively believe that God does not exist; it's just that we don't believe that he does exist." Atheism is not a positive belief; it doesn't affirm anything. Atheism is not believing in God.


Here we have a kind of fallacy of redefining words to make one's view seem less radical. Atheists redefine their position so it may be perceived as more rationally intuitive than theism. It shifts the burden of proof onto the theist. An atheist would say, "We don't need to prove that God does not exist; the theist must prove that He does exist." Put differently, “Atheism isn’t making any claim about reality; they just don't believe in the extra claim that theists make.” What atheists attempt to do is avoid the need for evidence and to make their own view the "default view. This is a sort of apologetic maneuver that cannot go unchallenged. The redefining of atheism contains two faults: (1) It mispresents atheism and (2) it misrepresents the burden of proof.


(1) It mispresents atheism:


Theism is a claim to know something about reality—that God exists. Atheism is likewise a claim to know something about reality—that God does not exist. If theism makes the positive claim that God exists, atheists reject that claim; they too make a truth claim. Since atheism, like theism, makes a truth claim, atheists require evidence to support their truth claim. Otherwise, belief in atheism would be irrational.


(2) It misrepresents the burden of proof:


Take this illustration: Babies are born without the intellectual capacities to comprehend much of anything about God and therefore cannot believe in God. Hence, all children are born atheists. It is only once they grow up and are conditioned into religion that belief in God appears. Until this occurs, they are considered atheists.


This represents the fallacious view of atheism. No, babies are not born atheists. Since they cannot express belief in God, they also cannot deny God's existence. They are unable to answer the question of God's existence, whether theism or atheism.


Now a truthful illustration of atheism as follows: If you were asked whether extraterrestrial life exists somewhere in the universe, you may answer any of the three: "I believe it does," "I don't believe so," or "I haven't made up my mind yet." The first two responses require a burden of proof because they make positive claims about reality: namely, that extraterrestrial life does or does not exist somewhere in the universe. It would be silly to say that the second response, the one that denies the existence of extraterrestrial life, holds to the default view, as if denying extraterrestrial life were something we all innately hold without external conditioning. If you had never heard of extraterrestrial life, you would not deny their existence; you simply wouldn't know.


The third response to extraterrestrial life, that their minds have yet to be made up, represents an agnostic view. If there is such a thing as a default position, it would be such. Agnosticism, rather than atheism, is "neutral" insofar as it withholds belief.


With a proper understanding of atheism, the answer to the question of "Is Atheism the default position?" is easy. Atheism is most certainly not a default position because atheism is a belief itself: God does not exist.

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page